19/11/2026 0 Kommentare
Evensong
Evensong
# Predigt

Evensong
Grace and peace to you, brothers and sisters.
If we are completely honest with ourselves, every single person in this room has looked at the world, or looked at their own life, and asked some version of the question: Where is God? We see devastation in the news, we watch severe illnesses such as cancer stealing the lives of our beloved, we witness corruption running rampant through the halls of power, and we cry out into what feels like a cold empty void.
Philosophers have a clinical, academic term for this agonized cry. They call it the problem of evil or theodicy—a word coined by the philosopher Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz in 1710, combining the Greek words Theos (God) and dike (justice). Theodicy is the attempt to vindicate or defend God’s goodness and omnipotence in the face of a world saturated with evil.
The Greek philosopher Epicurus famously laid down the ultimate philosophical trap: Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able? Then he is impotent. Is he able, but not willing? Then he is malevolent. If he is both able and willing, then from whence cometh evil?
For centuries, academics have treated this like a chess match. But today, we open the Book of Habakkuk, and we find that long before the philosophers turned the problem of evil into an intellectual debate, the prophets turned it into a prayer. Habakkuk does not give us a clinical thesis; he gives us a raw, bleeding lament. He shows us that the question of theodicy is not an academic puzzle to be solved—it is a spiritual trauma to be lived through.
Listen to how our text bursts open: “O Lord, how long shall I cry for help, and you will not hear? Or cry to you ‘Violence!’ and you will not save?”
Habakkuk is living in Judah around 600 B.C. Society is decaying from the inside out. Tyranny, greed and moral decay surround him. And yet, when Habakkuk looks up to heaven, it looks like God has gone silent.
Notice what Habakkuk does not do. He does not bury his doubts. He does not slap an artificial smile on his face and pretend everything is fine. Instead, he protests.
John Calvin, reflecting on this text, noted that the prophet's complaints were born not of unbelief, but out of a deep, burning zeal for God’s honour. Habakkuk cries out precisely because he has faith. If he didn't believe God was good, he wouldn't care that the world is bad.
Biblical faith leaves room for honest protest. God is not fragile. He can handle your tears, your "how long?" and your "why?"
In verse 3, Habakkuk asks: “Why do you make me see iniquity, and why do you idly look at wrong?”
The Hebrew word Habakkuk uses for violence here is chamas—a word describing systemic corruption, physical cruelty, and a total disregard for human dignity. Habakkuk feels trapped. He says, “Destruction and violence are before me; strife and contention arise.”
This points to a truth later voiced by philosopher Nicholas Wolterstorff after the tragic death of his son.
Wolterstorff wrote: "Instead of explaining the suffering, God shares it."
Habakkuk feels the pain of his community because he knows it pains the heart of God.
Because of God's apparent silence, Habakkuk witnesses a terrifying breakdown. He says: “So the law is paralyzed, and justice never goes forth.”
When the very legal structures meant to protect the vulnerable become tools of exploitation, the faithful suffer a profound spiritual vertigo.
God's response only sharpens the crisis. He tells Habakkuk that He is raising up the Chaldeans — the fierce, ruthless Babylonian empire whose “justice and dignity proceed from themselves.” God’s immediate answer to systemic injustice is to allow an even more brutal empire to sweep through.
How does Habakkuk survive this terror?
In verse 12, he anchors his soul in God's eternal nature: “Are you not from everlasting, O Lord my God, my Holy One? ... O Rock, you have established them for reproof.”
He clings to the identity of God even when God's methods terrify him.
We do not have to look back to 600 B.C. to understand this paralysis. We see it vividly in the 20th century during the years of the Nazi regime. Throughout the Third Reich the German legal system did not just fail; it was systematically hijacked. Through the Gleichschaltung, the entire judiciary was weaponized to serve totalitarian terror. Laws were crafted to legitimize the stripping of rights, forced deportations, and the industrialized slaughter of millions of Jewish people and political dissidents. The law was worse than paralyzed—it became the primary instrument of absolute wickedness.
It was in this concrete abyss that the theologian and martyr Dietrich Bonhoeffer wrestled with the crushing weight of structural sin. Writing from a cell in Tegel Prison, Bonhoeffer urged Christians to view world events "from below"—through the eyes of the suffering, oppressed, and excluded.
In April 1945, as the regime collapsed into final, desperate violence, Bonhoeffer was moved to the Flossenbürg concentration camp. The legal system offered him no protection; the highest judges of the Reich had personally signed his death warrant.
On the night before he was led to the gallows, stripped of his clothes and staring into the face of execution, Bonhoeffer was recorded by fellow prisoners as maintaining a profound, supernatural peace. He held a final prayer service for his cellmates, speaking of the enduring reality of God’s kingdom even as the walls around them crumbled.
Bonhoeffer did not receive a textbook explanation for why God allowed such darkness. Instead, he received the persisting faith and the spiritual stamina to look at a demonic legal system and choose the path of faithful endurance anyway.
Before walking to the place of execution, he whispered to a British cellmate: "This is the end—for me, the beginning of life."
Standing with Bonhoeffer in his cell, or with Habakkuk on his crumbling watchtower, we must ask: Why is the law so helpless against evil? Why can’t human rules or even God’s own commandments patch up the brokenness of our world?
To answer this, the Apostle Paul takes us by the hand in Galatians chapter 3 and walks us right into the heart of Habakkuk’s trauma.
Paul diagnoses the exact same spiritual vertigo. He looks at the law and strips away all our legalistic illusions. In Galatians 3:10, Paul drops a bombshell: “For all who rely on works of the law are under a curse.”
The law was never designed to be a saviour; it was designed to be a mirror. The law can expose corruption, define evil, and point out our guilt,—but it possesses zero power to transform the human heart. It can condemn the oppressor, but it cannot resurrect the oppressed. If we rely on human legal systems for cosmic justice, we will remain trapped under a curse, because human power bends toward self-interest.
Where, then, is our hope?
We do what Habakkuk did. We take our stand at the watch post, we station ourselves on the tower, waiting and listening for God to reveal his marching orders.
And what does God say to Habakkuk, and to us?
He says: “The righteous shall live by his faith.” (Hab 2:4).
Paul quotes this exact phrase in Galatians 3:11 to establish the foundation of Christian life: when courts are corrupt and heaven feels silent, the only way to endure without losing your soul is an unyielding, radical trust in God.
But Paul goes one step further than Habakkuk ever could. Habakkuk had to wait for a deferred answer. He had to look forward into a dark, uncertain future. But we live on the other side of the cross.
Paul shows us that God did not just send a philosophical answer to our protest; He sent His own Son to absorb the curse itself. As Galatians 3:13 declares: “Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us.”
When you feel the weight of systemic injustice, look to Golgotha.
On that Roman cross, Jesus Christ put Himself under the ultimate perversion of justice. He was innocent, yet surrounded by the wicked. He experienced the terrifying silence of the Father, crying out Habakkuk’s ultimate lament: “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?”
God did not remain an idle spectator to our suffering. In Christ, He climbed onto the tree of shame. He allowed Himself to be crushed by the very violence Habakkuk protested against, so that the power of that violence could be broken forever.
Through this cosmic act of solidarity and redemption, the landscape changes entirely. Paul concludes in Galatians 3:26–28 that through faith in this crucified Christ, we are no longer defined by the fractures of a broken world. We are no longer defined by the dividing lines of systemic oppression—there is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for we are all one in Christ Jesus. The law was paralyzed, but Christ is alive. The system failed, but grace triumphed.
Church, how does our reading end? It doesn't end with a neat little answer. The Book of Habakkuk offers what theologians call a "deferred theodicy." It challenges any cheap theology that demands an immediate, happy explanation for suffering or expects systemic injustices to be erased overnight.
Instead, Habakkuk anchors us for the long haul. God gives him a core thesis that would later spark the Reformation and redefine the New Testament: “The righteous shall live by his faith.” Not by sight, not by flawless philosophical explanations, but by absolute trust in the character of God.
If you are hurting today, if you are angry at the injustices of this world, know this: You are in prophetic company.
Do not walk away from God because of the mess; bring the mess to God.
Like Habakkuk, and like the saints who marched for justice in our own era, stand on the watchtower, weep, protest, and wait.
For the vision has an appointed time, and though it tarries, it will surely come.
And the peace of God, which passes all understanding, keep your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus.
Amen.
Propst Lars Dedekind
Kommentare